With on-demand delivery gaining immense significance nowadays, the amount of food delivery apps available in the market seems uncountable. This paves a lucrative opportunity for drivers who want to make extra income and achieve their goals. And one of the best ways to earn quick money is through delivery apps such as Postmates and DoorDash, which have become remarkably popular these days. Food order delivery does not require specialized skills and is simple to start with. However, choice varies based on features. Choosing between these two delivery companies can be a dilemma, especially when you want to make good money as a gig worker. Both the apps function similarly but there are certain things to consider when considering driving for each service.
This guide provides a detailed comparison of both the food delivery apps, helping you make a wise decision. So, let’s get started.
All views expressed in this website are my own, and do not represent the opinion of any entities whatsoever with which I have been, am now or will be affiliated.
Postmates is one of the top-notch and reliable on-demand food delivery services app that enables delivering anything from anywhere in the U.S. It is a cutting-edge food and grocery delivery platform that enables customers to order and get delivery for food, drinks, groceries, or anything they crave for – anywhere and anytime.
DoorDash is a modern food delivery app that lets customers choose from over 300,000 national and local dishes from across the United States and Canada. The app connects its users to restaurants nationwide, enabling them to connect with their restaurant of choice and order their favorites online in a prompt and hassle-free manner.
While both the apps provide fantastic opportunities to earn quick money as a gig driver, the biggest difference between the two is that with DoorDash you will be involved only in food delivery, while Postmates has a broader scope that facilitates delivering literally anything and anywhere nationwide.
Both Postmates app and DoorDash app work similarly for drivers who want to make some additional income by leveraging the fast-growing popularity of on-demand delivery apps. Here we will understand how both the apps work for drivers.
When you sign into the Postmates service app and receive the first delivery order, you will drive to the store or restaurant to pick up the order on time. Since the app facilitates ordering anything from anywhere, it uses a map to pick the nearest delivery person. This helps meet the delivery deadline and offer exceptional quality customer service.
As a Postmates driver, you will receive a credit card that allows you to make every purchase that comes as a customer order. All payments including delivery fees will be paid to the vendor through this Postmates credit card. Upon purchasing the goods, you will drive to the customer by following the heat map and deliver them to the customer on time.
Since Postmates guarantees its customers delivering anything, anywhere and anytime, it is important for the drivers to operate at any given time. The app does not have any option for drivers to schedule their shifts and you might have to drive any day or anytime of the day. So, if you are ready to work with flexible timings, Postmates may be an ideal choice for you.
When you work as a driver with DoorDash, you will receive notifications for your delivery describing remuneration for completing the order. It depends solely on you whether to accept or decline the order. Upon receiving the order, you have to drive to the partner restaurant to pick up the specific order and purchase the food with your DoorDash Red Card.
It is an exclusive prepaid card that you will use to make payment for food at various restaurants. However, not every order you receive will require buying through the card. For orders that specify “Place Order” or “Pay with Red Card” will need you to pay via the prepaid card.
Next, you have to pick up the order once the food is prepared and drive to the customer’s precise location to drop off. It is a breeze working with DoorDash, but the working hours are less flexible than Postmates. The hours of work will vary depending on one city to another, but drivers do not have the choice to work 24/7.
Moreover, there are two unique forms of Dashing available to drivers. Firstly, you can schedule a future dash by signing into the app and choosing your preferred day, start and end time. An advantage of scheduling your dash shift is you will have a guaranteed spot in the chosen time slot, irrespective of the number of drivers available at that time.
Another option available to drivers is Dash Now. It is as simple as opening the application at any time of the day and start driving. However, a limitation is that you might not be able to drive at any specific time. This is a unique feature of DoorDash, i.e. it limits the number of Dashers driving at any particular time.
After all, it does not want you to get started and then not having sufficient work to earn a good amount of money. While this may otherwise be an advantage, a drawback is that if you choose Dash Now, it will limit you to drive in your preferred area at any desired time.
Winner: With flexible scheduling options and convenient working hours, Postmates is a clear winner in this segment. Scheduling your preferred working hours is difficult with DoorDash.
The Fleet app is intuitive and simple to use. The smooth layout presents things in a manner that is easy to comprehend. However, one of the biggest advantages of Postmates is an interactive heat map built in the app that makes navigation through the city streets quick and seamless.
This will help you meet multiple delivery orders in an hour, improving your chances of earning more money in the quickest possible time. The app also aids in batch orders that can further help boost your income in the long run.
The Dasher app is remarkably easy to use and the layout is clean, which makes it easier for drivers to understand the key features in an efficient manner. Using the app is a breeze, but the biggest advantage of the Dasher app is that you can choose your default map. To make easier for drivers to reach the destination on time because, they can switch the default Google map application with Waze to find directions. If you drive for DoorDash, the flexibility of batch orders is also available.
Winner:Tie DoorDash app and Postmates fleet app are crisp and clean app. The design that delivers improved user experience as a delivery driver. All the critical features such as batching are well implemented and you do not need to tap buttons continuously.
Even the top-notch delivery app in the world is ineffective if it does not provide service in your area. For a gig worker considering earning quick money through nationwide delivery, the availability of the service plays an integral role. Therefore, it is important to consider which is available in more cities – Postmates or DoorDash.
With a reach across 3,500 cities, Postmates is certainly a winner here. DoorDash is now available in 3,000 cities , including certain areas of Canada and Australia as well. Therefore, the latter does not offer a nationwide advantage as compared to Postmates.
Winner: With a broader reach and better income-earning scope for drivers, Postmates has an added advantage over DoorDash where the app is still working to maximize its penetration and partner with more restaurants across the United States and Canada.
Pitting Doordash vs Postmates, we take a look at the respective strengths of each platform. Both the delivery gigs provide attractive opportunities to make money based on the total number of orders you fulfill. There is no system for hourly wages and you get paid only for the orders that you deliver. However, both apps also provide the option to make more money through a tipping system. To help you make a wise decision, let’s see which platform provides a better income-earning opportunity.
The driver’s pay on Postmates is calculated on the basis of pickup fee, drop fee, the mileage rate between pickup and drop, and the total time it takes from pickup to reach the customer. The app does not pay you for the trip from your location to the pickup point. Instead you will get a flat rate for every pick up. Take a look at your market earnings.
When the demand is high, you can make advantage of blitz pricing, which is applied as 1.25-1.75x multiplier. This lets you earn most money during the busiest times, enabling you to make the most from peak pricing strategy. The delivery platform also allows users to tip the driver inside the app once the order is complete.
The driver’s pay on DoorDash is calculated on the basis of Base Pay + Promotions + Tips. Base pay of the driver is determined as per the distance, time, and desirability. Before you accept an order, an estimated payout will be displayed.
You can choose to accept or decline the order if the payout is not satisfactory. However, the starting payout for drivers is $6 per delivery. Regardless of how negligible the delivery cost is, as a driver you will receive a minimum of $6.
During busy times, the app provides “Peak Pay” promotions that allow you to earn a bonus on each delivery. This can range from $8-$15 per hour during high-demand hours. Tips from customers are another fantastic way of making money on DoorDash.
Winner: With a minimum payout of $6, DoorDash is an obvious winner when the pay structure is concerned. Furthermore, it lets you accept or decline orders based on the estimated payout amount. This is a great advantage over Postmates because the latter provides no option to decline the lowest payout orders.
Now let’s compare the application process for both Postmates and DoorDash – which provides a more convenient, quick and hassle-free signup option for the drivers?
The core requirements to become a driver with Postmates and DoorDash are quite similar. To make money as a delivery driver on both platforms, you must meet the following requirements:
The vehicle requirements are also similar for both the delivery apps and are minimalist to help you become a driver and earn money seamlessly. Whether you are driving a two-wheeler or a four-wheeler, both the apps require you to provide valid vehicle insurance, driver’s license, and your own insurance. Based on city requirements, you are also eligible to deliver via a bike, scooter, or even walking.
A background verification check is mandatory for driver recruitments with any of the two delivery apps. It covers evaluating whether you have a criminal background in violent crime, theft, sexual offences, DUI, felonies, or property damage. Additionally, if you choose to deliver via a motorcycle or car, it will also include your Motor Vehicles Record. This includes checking the status and validity of your driver’s license, driving record points, traffic accidents, DUI public reports, and traffic law violations with fines and convictions.
Winner: Since the requirements are the same, it is a tie between both the delivery apps.
Signing up with both Postmates and DoorDash is simple and quick. Additionally, they offer an attractive signup bonus amount for guaranteed earnings. However, to claim the bonus amount with Postmates, you have to fulfill 30-60 deliveries within the first 30 days. The number of deliveries to claim signup up bonus with DoorDash is 120-150 in the first 60 days. Both apps also provide the option to earn extra money through a referral system. But DoorDash allows adding only 15 drivers per year.
Winner: Here also it is a tie situation for Postmates vs DoorDash because their signup process and terms & conditions to claim bonus amounts are quite similar.
Both Postmates and DoorDash have their respective pros and cons, which we have clearly outlined in the review above. Payment options are more lucrative with DoorDash. Other factors including flexible work hours without scheduling options and the binary rating system for drivers, make Postmates attractive. Additionally, driver and vehicle requirements are also more lenient with the latter. To determine which on-demand delivery option is best for you as a driver, it is crucial to evaluate which fits better to your schedule, renders a greater pay, and helps achieve desired results.
Sign up bonuses are the best way to increase your earnings and make cash fast. Our Uber/UberEats promo code and Lyft referral promo code will give you the best bonus at any given time.
Get $1,000 Lyft new driver guaranteed
LYFT driver promotion
Get up to $1000 new Driver Sign-up Bonus
Join Postmates fleet today! Set up your Postmates Account and start to earn money